Guide · 12 min read

What to write under a one-star review, and the kind of reply that cost a dental practice $10,000

Answering a bad review with the facts has cost dental practices HIPAA settlements. What a reply can never say, what a safe one says, and how to hear it first.

It is late in the evening and a new review has appeared on your Google profile. One star. It says the office overcharged and nobody explained the bill, and parts of it are simply wrong. You know what was said, what was done and what the insurance paid, and the instinct is to set the record straight, in public, before the next person searching for a dentist reads it.

Replies like that have cost dental practices money. In 2019 a practice in Dallas agreed to pay $10,000 to the federal office that enforces HIPAA, after the office found that its replies to reviews had disclosed patients' health information; in 2022 a practice in California paid $23,000 over the same kind of replies. This guide covers what a reply can never say, what a safe one says instead, what federal rules forbid a practice to do about a bad review, and how to hear the complaint first.

The replies that cost two dental practices

Elite Dental Associates is a privately owned practice in Dallas. In June 2016, a patient complained to the Office for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services that the practice had responded to a review by disclosing the patient's last name and details of the patient's health condition. The office's investigation found that the practice had disclosed the information of multiple patients in replies to their reviews on its Yelp page, and that it had no policy to make sure its social media interactions protected patient information. The practice agreed to pay $10,000 and to a corrective action plan with two years of monitoring; the office said it had accepted a substantially reduced amount in view of the practice's size, finances and cooperation. "Social media is not the place for providers to discuss a patient's care," said Roger Severino, then the office's director.

New Vision Dental, a general practice in South Pasadena and Glendora, California, drew a complaint in November 2017. According to the complaint, the practice habitually disclosed patient information when it replied to reviews on Yelp, sometimes giving full names where patients had posted under only a Yelp nickname, and details of visits and insurance their reviews may not have mentioned. The office confirmed that the practice had been posting replies that compromised patient information. In 2022 the practice paid $23,000 and agreed to two years of monitoring, with written policies limiting the use and disclosure of patient information in email, on the internet and on social media sites to the minimum necessary, and training for everyone on its staff. Melanie Fontes Rainer, then the office's director, said providers "cannot disclose protected health information of their patients when responding to negative online reviews."

Neither agreement is an admission of liability.

Why the facts are the problem

A reply feels like a conversation with one person. It is a public post, under the practice's name, visible to everyone who looks at the profile from then on.

HIPAA protects information that identifies a person and relates to their health, the care they received or the payment for it, and it defines disclosure as divulging information in any manner outside the practice. A reply that names a patient, or mentions a treatment, a visit, an insurance plan or a balance, divulges exactly that kind of information, however accurate the reply and however unfair the review. The reviewer may say what they like about their own care. The practice cannot answer in kind: in both settlements, the disclosures were the practices' own replies.

"As we explained at your visit last Tuesday" is about a person's care. So is "we're sorry the crown came off." HHS's own guidance gives an example of protected information: a name listed with "an indication that the individual was treated at a certain clinic." So even a reply that only confirms the reviewer was a patient can disclose it. The safe rule is simpler than the law: a public reply never confirms, denies or discusses anyone's care, including what the reviewer has already posted, and never adds a name the reviewer did not use.

Google's tips for replies, written for every kind of business, suggest addressing the reviewer by name and acknowledging their specific feedback. A dental practice has to leave out the second half.

What a safe reply says

A safe reply does three things. It thanks the reviewer. It says, in general terms, what the practice stands for. And it offers a private way to talk: a phone number, an email address, the name of the person who will take the call. Google's own guidance on negative reviews points the same way: never share a reviewer's private information, and when a situation is complex, ask them to contact you by phone or email to resolve it privately.

For example:

"Thank you for taking the time to tell us this. We want every visit here to go well, and we take what you've written seriously. Privacy rules keep us from discussing anyone's care in a public reply, but we'd welcome the chance to talk. Please call [name], our office manager, at [phone number]."

That reply confirms nothing and discloses nothing, and it reads well to the person it is really written for: the stranger deciding where to book. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey of US consumers, 89% said they expect a business to respond to the reviews they write, and templated or generic responses made 50% unlikely to choose a business. So the privacy line never changes, but the rest is written fresh each time, in the practice's own voice.

Three habits help. A second person reads each draft before it posts. The reply goes up promptly, as Google suggests, but never in the first hour after the review lands. And the practice replies once; if the reviewer answers back, the next step is private.

If the practice can tell who wrote the review, that conversation belongs on the phone: what happened, and what can be put right. It can never include an offer for the review. Google prohibits incentives, such as free or discounted goods or services, for changing or removing a negative review. A practice can fix the problem; whether the review changes is the patient's decision, though Google notes that following up on concerns may even encourage a customer to update a review.

Hear the complaint before it is posted

The safest reply is the one never needed. A patient can leave unhappy without saying a word at the desk, and the first the practice hears of it may be the review. The fix is to ask everyone how it went, every visit, before they leave: a two-question survey at checkout, how likely are you to refer us and how likely are you to leave us a review, each scored to ten. The guide on referrals and reviews covers the survey and the moment to send it.

A score of six or below is a patient to call the same day, while the visit is fresh and the problem can still be fixed. As Dr. Prachi Deore puts it in the protocol's own training: "A low score caught early is feedback gold. A low score ignored becomes a bad review."

The call is not a request to stay quiet. Google does not allow a business to discourage negative reviews, and the unhappy patient gets the same invitation to review as everyone else. The call is about the problem.

Patient Pipeline runs that loop. It sends the survey by text and email from the patient's record, with room for a comment, and its survey results page counts the patients who scored six or below on the question you choose, above a list of every answer with the patient's name, score, date and remarks that can be sorted by score. Once the practice has added its Google review link, every patient who completes the survey gets the review request by email, pointing at that page, whatever they scored, repeated on the twenty-first until they have been asked three times in all. It does not reply to reviews or watch Google for new ones; the reply and the call are the practice's.

Want the unhappy patient's answer in front of you while there is still time to call: a two-question survey at checkout, the low scores counted for you, and the same review invitation for everyone who answers? The 100 Day Profit Reset Protocol is free for your first hundred days — every tool, no credit card, nothing to cancel.

Start the 100 Day Protocol Free

What the rules now forbid

Since October 21, 2024, a Federal Trade Commission rule on consumer reviews has named several of the temptations a bad review brings, and because it is a rule, the FTC can seek civil penalties against knowing violators. Four parts of it bear on a one-star review:

  • No threats to make it go away. The rule forbids a groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a public accusation the business knows is false, or makes with reckless disregard for the truth, used in an attempt to stop a review being written or to get one removed.
  • No fake reviews to bury it. A business may not write reviews that misrepresent that the reviewer exists or had any experience with it, or buy reviews it knew or should have known were fake.
  • No paying for the stars. A business may not provide compensation or other incentives in exchange for, or conditioned on, reviews expressing a particular sentiment, positive or negative.
  • No undisclosed reviews from the inside. An officer or manager may not review the business without clearly disclosing the relationship, and one who asks staff or immediate family for reviews can break the rule if a review appears without that disclosure and the officer or manager discouraged it, did not tell reviewers to disclose, or knew or should have known and did nothing. Google goes further: it does not allow reviews based on a conflict of interest, including current or former employment and family relationships.

Google's own policy adds two more: a business may not discourage negative reviews, and it may not selectively solicit positive ones. The referrals guide explains why inviting only the happy patients is also what the FTC's endorsement guides describe as potentially deceptive.

Can Google take the review down? Only if it breaks Google's rules. Google says only reviews that violate its policies are eligible for removal, that a business should not report one just because it disagrees with it, and that Google does not get involved in conflicts between businesses and customers. A fake review, an off-topic one or one from a competitor is worth reporting. One that is merely negative is not.

Ask everyone, and one review stops being the whole story

The lasting answer to one bad review is a steady flow of honest ones. The arithmetic: on a profile with eight five-star reviews, one more at one star pulls the average to about 4.6; on a profile with eighty, to about 4.95. Recency matters as well. In the same BrightLocal survey, 74% said they only care about reviews written in the last three months, so last year's praise may do little against this week's complaint.

The steady flow comes from asking every patient, the same way, while the visit is fresh: an invitation by email, right after the survey, to write on their own time. Never only the happy ones, and never with pressure at the desk: Google asks that businesses not require or pressure customers to review while on the premises.

Asked this way, the unhappy patient is invited too, and one bad review sits among honest ones instead of standing alone.

What one practice measured

Dr. Prachi Deore runs Coppell Smiles, a private practice in Coppell, Texas, and hers was the first practice on Profit Smiles: the tools were proven there before they were offered to anyone else.

Her practice added the survey at checkout and let it find her promoters. None of her results is a review count, because reviews land on Google, outside the platform. The same survey's other half is measured: in the first ninety days, monthly referrals went from ten to twenty-one, from patients she already had.

Her results are one practice's results, measured in the platform, and individual results vary.

Run it in your own practice

Four steps for this week:

  1. Write the reply standard down: who replies, who reads the draft, the three things a reply says and the things it never says. Both settlements required written privacy policies; yours can exist before anyone complains.
  2. Read your existing replies, on Google, Yelp and anywhere else, against that list. Any reply that names a patient or discusses their care should come down, and it is worth asking your privacy officer or attorney what else it requires.
  3. Start the two-question survey at checkout, and call every six or below the same day.
  4. Invite every patient to review the same way, whatever they scored.

The free patient attrition calculator on this site puts a number on the patients who drift away: the production that walks out with them each year, and the acquisition spend wasted on new patients who never return.

Sources

  • U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, "Dental Practice Pays $10,000 to Settle Social Media Disclosures of Patients' Protected Health Information" (press release, October 2, 2019), with the Elite Dental Associates – Dallas, P.C. resolution agreement; and "HHS Civil Rights Office Enters Settlement with Dental Practice Over Disclosures of Patients' Protected Health Information" (press release, December 14, 2022), with the B. Brandon Au, DDS, Inc., d/b/a New Vision Dental resolution agreement and corrective action plan.
  • 45 CFR § 160.103, the definitions of individually identifiable health information and of disclosure (eCFR, current as of November 12, 2026); HHS, Guidance Regarding Methods for De-identification of Protected Health Information (content last reviewed February 3, 2025).
  • Federal Trade Commission, Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465 (89 FR 68034, August 22, 2024; effective October 21, 2024), §§ 465.2, 465.4, 465.5 and 465.7(a); FTC press release, August 14, 2024, on civil penalties against knowing violators.
  • Google Business Profile Help, Tips to get more reviews and Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile; Google Maps User Generated Content Policy, Prohibited & restricted content.
  • BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (February 2026; 1,002 US adult consumers): 89% expect a business to respond to reviews they write; templated or generic responses make 50% unlikely to choose a business; 74% only care about reviews written in the last three months.
  • The safe rule, the safe reply and its sample, the three habits, the private call and the call after a low score are working practice, not measured predictors. Dr. Prachi Deore's results (monthly referrals from ten to twenty-one in the first ninety days) are those of one practice, measured in the platform, and individual results vary. This guide is not legal advice; for a reply you are unsure of, or a disclosure that has already happened, ask your attorney.

Run your own numbers

The arithmetic from this guide, as free calculators — each opens with an example practice's figures; replace them with yours.

Patient Attrition Cost Calculator

What do the patients who quietly stop coming back cost you each year — including the ones you paid to acquire?

Open the calculator →

The tool that does this

Patient Pipeline — Turn the patients you already have into your main source of new ones. What Patient Pipeline does →

Results shown are from one practice following this protocol. Individual results may vary.

More guides

All guides · The calculators · The seven tools

Run this on your own numbers — free for a hundred days.

The protocol records your practice's baseline on day one, and every tool shows its dollar impact against it. No credit card, nothing to cancel.

Start the 100 Day Protocol Free

Free for 100 days · No credit card · Built by a practicing dentist