Guide · 12 min read

Should you raise your dental fees? What a raise does on an in-network claim, and where it reaches the bank

On a PPO patient, the plan's allowed fee is the price, so a raise mostly grows the write-off. Where a fee increase does reach the bank, and what to check first.

Costs go up, so the fee schedule goes up. It is the most natural move in practice finance: raise every fee ten percent and collections should follow. In a practice where nearly every patient carries PPO insurance, they barely move, and the owner is left wondering where the raise went.

The pressure behind the instinct is real. Since January 2021, the all-payer reimbursement index the ADA Health Policy Institute tracks has risen 19% while inflation has run 27%, so a fee schedule that has not moved since then is worth less in real terms. But on a PPO patient, your fee is not the price. The plan's allowed fee is. This guide covers what a raise actually does on an in-network claim, the codes and services where it does reach the bank, the patients for whom your fee is the whole price, and what to check before you change a single number.

Two prices for every procedure

Every procedure you perform has two prices. The first is your office fee: the fee you charge a patient who has no insurance, and the one that belongs on every claim you send. The second is the plan's allowed fee: the most a PPO allows in total for that procedure, its share and the patient's share together, listed in the plan's fee schedule, which you can request from the plan if you do not have it.

When an in-network patient sits in your chair, the allowed fee decides what you collect. The plan pays its share of the allowed fee, the patient pays the rest of it, and the gap between your office fee and the allowed fee is written off. Under the contract, the patient cannot be billed for that gap on a covered service: the State of Delaware's employee dental plan with Delta Dental of Delaware, for example, says its PPO providers accept contracted fees as payment in full for covered services and will not balance bill.

That gap is the contracted write-off, and across a PPO-heavy practice it takes 30–50% of gross production, the range Profit Smiles uses throughout. How it differs from plan to plan, and what leaving a plan would cost, is the subject of the guide to dropping a PPO. This guide is about the other number in the gap: yours.

What a raise does on an in-network claim

Raise your office fee and the allowed fee on your next claim does not move. The plan calculates its payment, and the patient's share, from its own schedule. Delta Dental's guidance to dentists gives the example: if a dentist submits a fee of one hundred twenty dollars and the allowance is one hundred, both payments are calculated on one hundred. If your fee was already above the allowance, the in-network claim pays exactly what it paid before the raise.

What does change is the write-off. Say a plan allows 70% of your office fee for a crown. Raise the fee by 10% and the plan still allows what it allowed before, which is now about 64% of the new fee. On paper, the write-off on that crown has grown from 30% to about 36%. In the bank, nothing has changed.

That matters to anyone who watches the gap between production and collections, the number the six-number check starts with. After a raise, production at your fees goes up across the board, collections go up only where your fee is the price, and the gap widens. So when you compare the period before a fee change with the period after it, compare what you collected per visit, not the write-off percentage.

The heavier a practice's PPO mix, the less a raise does. Where nearly every patient is in network, a ten percent increase can leave collections almost exactly where they were.

The codes where a raise does reach the bank

There is one in-network case where a raise pays, and it sits in the contracts' own wording. The State of Delaware's employee dental plan, underwritten by Delta Dental of Delaware, defines the allowance for a PPO provider as the lesser of the provider's submitted fee or the Delta Dental PPO contracted fee. Delta Dental of Massachusetts, a separate company, defines the maximum plan allowance in its participating dentist agreements the same way: the lesser of the participating dentist's submitted fee or the maximum fee Delta Dental approves for the procedure in a given region and/or specialty under normal circumstances.

Under a lesser-of clause, the allowance in normal circumstances cannot exceed the fee you submit. If your office fee for a code is below a plan's allowed fee for it, the plan pays on your fee, and the difference is money the contract would have let you collect. A fee schedule that has not been reviewed in years can carry codes like that, priced below what one or more of your plans would allow.

For those codes, a raise reaches the bank on every claim from a plan that allows more, up to that plan's allowance. To find them, set each frequently used code's office fee beside the highest allowed fee any of your plans sets for it. Any code priced below that number is underpriced for every plan that allows more.

Two cautions. A raise on such a code also raises what uninsured patients pay for it, and what members of an in-house plan pay after their discount, so set it deliberately rather than by habit. And send your office fee on every claim, whatever the plan allows. The ADA's advice is to report your own fee on the claim form and let the payer adjust it to the contracted amount. Under a lesser-of clause, a claim submitted at a plan's fee is allowed at no more than that fee.

Want your office fee set beside every plan's allowed fee, code by code, as you enter each plan's fee schedule? The 100 Day Profit Reset Protocol is free for your first hundred days — every tool, no credit card, nothing to cancel.

Start the 100 Day Protocol Free

Services the plan does not cover

The second place a raise can reach is work a plan does not cover, and whether a PPO can set your fee there depends on your state and your contract. According to the ADA, as of March 2026, forty-four states have noncovered services laws that stop plans from dictating a provider's fee for procedures the plan does not cover. In the remaining six, South Carolina, Delaware, New York, Michigan, Massachusetts and Hawaii, the PPO contract is the key to what you can charge.

Covered and paid are not the same thing. A service can be covered and still not paid: the patient's annual maximum is used up, a frequency limit has been exceeded, the deductible has not been met, or a waiting period is still running. In those cases, the ADA warns, you may still be bound to the contracted fee, depending on how your state defines a covered service.

The laws have a reach, too. They typically apply to fully insured plans regulated by the state's department of insurance, while self-funded plans, typically governed by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, may claim exemption from state insurance laws.

So the opening is narrower than it sounds. Where a state's law defines a covered service by benefit eligibility, as the ADA says most do, a service a fully insured plan never treats as a benefit is where your own fee can apply. Some states draw the line elsewhere: Iowa defines covered services as services the plan actually reimburses to some extent, and Nebraska leaves the term undefined. Your contracts, your state's law and the type of plan decide the rest.

Where your fee is the price

Outside the in-network claim, your office fee is the whole price, and a raise reaches every dollar of it. Three groups of patients pay it.

Patients with no dental insurance. According to CareQuest Institute's 2024 survey, 27% of US adults have none. They pay your office fee, which makes a raise real money, and a price change they will notice. And they include the callers who ask what a crown costs before they book, the call the price-shopper guide is about.

Out-of-network patients. A practice that leaves a network can still see that plan's patients and file their claims. The plan pays whatever out-of-network benefit it offers, the patient pays the balance up to your office fee, and with no contract in force for that plan, nothing requires a write-off. Leaving a network ends a contract, not the relationship with those patients.

Members of an in-house plan. In a membership plan priced as a discount off your office fee, a member pays your office fee less the discount, so the plan's member prices move with your fee schedule. Raise a code's office fee and its member price rises by the same percentage, because the discount is a share of the fee, not a fixed amount.

Add the noncovered services your state protects, and you have the share of your practice where your fee really is the price. That share is the number to know before any raise: what part of last month's production came from patients paying your own fee? If it is a sliver, a raise will feel like pushing on a rope.

The two levers that move a PPO-heavy practice

If the fee schedule cannot move a PPO-heavy practice, two things can, and neither is a fee.

Which plans you accept. A plan that allows 70% of your fee and a plan that allows 50% look the same on the schedule and are not the same business. Ranking every plan on what it actually pays, and running the break-even on the worst before leaving any, is the work in the PPO guide. This is the write-off side of the gap.

How many patients pay your own fee. Every member, every uninsured patient and every out-of-network patient who stays is a patient on whom your fee schedule works. A membership plan gives uninsured patients a reason to stay and a price they can plan around; the membership guide walks through starting one.

The fee schedule follows those two decisions. It cannot replace them.

Before you change a single fee

Six checks, in order, before the next increase:

  1. List your twenty to forty most-used codes with your office fee beside each plan's allowed fee for them.
  2. Mark every code priced below a plan's allowance. Raise those first, once you have decided what the new fee means for uninsured patients and members.
  3. Work out your own-fee share: the part of last month's production from uninsured patients, out-of-network patients, members, and the noncovered services your state protects.
  4. Check your state and each patient's plan. Is your state one of the forty-four with a noncovered services law, how does that law define a covered service, and is the patient's plan fully insured or self-funded? The ID card or summary plan description may name the employer as the plan's sponsor or refer to ERISA.
  5. Bill your office fee on every claim, whatever the plan allows, and let the payer adjust it.
  6. Judge the raise on collections, per visit and in total, never on the write-off rate, which climbs with every increase.

How one practice did it

Dr. Prachi Deore runs Coppell Smiles, a private practice in Coppell, Texas, and hers was the first practice on Profit Smiles: the tools were proven there before they were offered to anyone else.

Her PPO result on record comes from the write-off side. She put every plan through the same math, what each one actually paid and what it wrote off, and checked what leaving each would cost before touching anything. Then she left the plans that lost money, about 80% of her plans by count of contracts, and kept one large plan deliberately, for now, because it carried a big share of her patients. Six months after dropping the unprofitable plans, her practice's monthly production was up $20,000.

She also runs a membership plan for her uninsured patients, which enrolled 48 members in its first ninety days.

As she puts it in the protocol's own training, "A write-off is the gap between two numbers — your fee for a procedure, and the insurance company's allowed fee." The change on record in her practice is to the second number: which plans' allowed fees bind it at all.

Her results are one practice's results, measured in the platform, and individual results vary.

Run your own numbers

Three free calculators on this site put numbers on the two levers: what your PPO plans write off each year, how many of a plan's patients you could lose by leaving its network and still collect the same production, and what a membership plan could bring in from the uninsured adults around your practice. Each opens with an example practice's figures; nothing you enter leaves your browser.

PPO Inspector sets your office fee beside every plan's allowed fee, code by code, from the fee schedules you enter: the write-off on each code and for each plan, and a negative write-off on any code priced below that plan's allowance. Add each plan's production and patient count, and it ranks the plans by profitability, with a what-if for leaving each one. Club Creator runs the membership plan: its fees and member discounts, the enrollment portal and member pricing at checkout. Both read the same office-fee list, so a fee changed once is changed for both, and each code's member fee follows its office fee.

Sources

  • ADA Health Policy Institute, The State of the U.S. Dental Economy, 3rd Quarter 2026 Update: the all-payer reimbursement index up 19% since January 2021 against 27% inflation.
  • State of Delaware, Dental Plan Evidence of Coverage, underwritten by Delta Dental of Delaware (effective July 1, 2026): the allowance for a PPO provider is the lesser of the provider's submitted fee or the PPO contracted fee, and PPO providers will not balance bill for covered services. Delta Dental, Maximum Contract Allowances (guidance for dentists, deltadentalins.com). Delta Dental of Massachusetts, Outline of Reimbursement for Participating Delta Dental Premier and Delta Dental PPO Dentists and Participating Group Practices (amended effective February 1, 2022).
  • Mary Beth Versaci, "Dear ADA: Noncovered services," ADA News, March 30, 2026: the forty-four states with noncovered services laws and the six without, how states define a covered service, services covered but not paid, fully insured and self-funded plans, and reporting your own fee on the claim.
  • CareQuest Institute for Oral Health, State of Oral Health Equity in America (2024 survey of more than 9,000 adults): 27% of US adults without dental insurance.
  • Write-offs of 30–50% of gross production is the range Profit Smiles uses across all of its materials. The crown and the two plans are worked examples, not measured figures. This guide is not legal advice; for what your contracts and your state's law allow, ask your attorney or your state dental association. Dr. Prachi Deore's results are those of one practice, measured in the platform; individual results vary.

Run your own numbers

The arithmetic from this guide, as free calculators — each opens with an example practice's figures; replace them with yours.

PPO Write-Off Calculator

How much of your production disappears into PPO fee schedules — and what would one more fee cut cost you?

Open the calculator →

Out-of-Network Break-Even Calculator

How many of a plan's patients could you lose by going out of network and still collect the same production?

Open the calculator →

Membership Plan Revenue Calculator

What could an in-house membership plan for uninsured patients be worth to your practice each year?

Open the calculator →

The tool that does this

PPO Inspector — See what each insurance plan really pays you — and decide with numbers, not nerves. What PPO Inspector does →

Club Creator — A membership plan for the patients who have no insurance at all. What Club Creator does →

Results shown are from one practice following this protocol. Individual results may vary.

More guides

All guides · The calculators · The seven tools

Run this on your own numbers — free for a hundred days.

The protocol records your practice's baseline on day one, and every tool shows its dollar impact against it. No credit card, nothing to cancel.

Start the 100 Day Protocol Free

Free for 100 days · No credit card · Built by a practicing dentist